I love food. I've never had to write a bad review before but my experience at this place really bummed me out.
Here's the review..
The Annona Bistro located at 2643 South Kinnickinnic Avenue in downtown Bayview is a newer place, just opening in the last year. My wife and I stopped in the other night in an effort to try something new. We may stop trying new things.
I had never been in Annona before and as I entered I was immediately impressed by how many tables they were able to get into such a small place. Some may say it makes the place look cluttered and they may be right. After a few minutes someone directed us to a table in back. As we made our way to the table we passed display cases showcasing the different sandwiches and fresh from the box deserts and a sign that advertised the soup of the day as Cheddar Broccoli.
Perusing the menu, which can be found on their website at annonabistro.com, they specialize in food with a Mediterranean flair. Some of their entrees sounded good, but my wife and I decided to have the soup and sandwich combo, as we were both hungry for some good Cheddar Broccoli soup and one of the delicious looking sandwiches we had seen on our way in. The very friendly waitress took our order and as we waited I perused the drink list. Apparently besides carrying the very good coffee roasted by the Anodyne Coffee Roasting Company, Annona has a full selection of cocktails featuring 11 varieties of martinis. When our soup arrived, it was abundantly apparent that it wasn’t Cheddar Broccoli. We chased down our waitress and asked her about this. She told us that they had forgotten to change the sign and the new soup was Curry Lentil. Neither of us being fans of lentils, we asked if we could get something else. After checking in the kitchen the waitress told my wife that she would be able to get a cup of the Broccoli Cheddar for her. I decided to try the “award-winning” Sweet Potato and Black Bean Chili. When it arrived, the Broccoli Cheddar was watery, almost as if the last scrapings from the pot had been stretched for a final bowl. As for my “award-winning” chili, it was good but certainly not what I would expect to win awards. It was a pretty pedestrian chili moderately seasoned with chili powder and little else.
Our sandwiches arrived, I had gotten the Roast Beef Panini and my wife got the Italian. Normally served with a pickle spear, chips, and a red pepper aioli, however when ordered as part of the soup combo you get none of these. No chips I can understand, but no pickle seems a bit stingy. We asked if we could still get some of the aioli and our waitress went and got us some gladly. The bread used for the paninis is absolutely wonderful, it’s certainly some of the best bread I have ever eaten. I tried to tell my wife this but was drowned out by the piano player that felt that playing loudly helped make for a relaxing atmosphere. I was disappointed that my sandwich consisted of only meat, cheese and few tomatoes; I felt some red onion would really complete it. My wife’s Italian Panini had some delicious Italian meats and good provolone, but the mild giardinera was sparse; a healthy portion would have really made this a good sandwich.
I would not say that the Annona Bistro is bad. It has really good bread. However, I would not recommend it. It seems like they have a lot of good ideas that don’t seem to have been thought out completely. Most of their dishes, if improved just slightly, have the potential to be really great. Until then, you’re better off going somewhere that gets it right.